Cases / Recently Settled Cases

EmCare - Envision Healthcare Surprise Billing Consumer Litigation

Court Issues Order Granting FinalApproval of Proposed Class Action Settlement

Judge Fernando M. Olguin of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California has granted final approval of the proposed class action settlement, finding that the settlement satisfies all the strict standards for approval.  The Court noted that "class members can potentially obtain 100% of the relief to which they are entitled."  A copy of the Court's decision can be found here.

Court Grants Preliminary Approval of Proposed Settlement and Schedules Final Approval Hearing

Judge Fernando M. Olguin of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California has granted preliminary approval of a proposed class action settlement (and a slight modification thereto) in this surprise billing consumer litigation.  Class Members, who were treated in emergency departments by physician practices affiliated with Defendants, may obtain monetary relief in two forms.  First, eligible Class Members who submit valid claims (“Claimants”) may obtain write-offs of any outstanding balances allegedly owed to Defendants; that is, Defendants will write-off the difference between Defendants’ billed rates and the “Allowable Charge(s)” that the Class Member’s health insurance plan determined, pursuant to federal regulations, represents reasonable reimbursement.  Second, Defendants will refund any payments made in excess of the Allowable Charge(s), including payments made after Defendants sold or otherwise transferred interest in the contested debt to a collection agency, to Claimants. 

The Settlement also provides nonmonetary benefits for the Class and the larger public through provisions requiring Defendants to request, in writing, that any hospital they contract with make certain specified disclosures, which would alert patients to the possibility of receiving out-of-network emergency department physician services in an in-network emergency department and allow patients to determine whether the emergency department physicians are in fact out-of-network.  In sum, the Settlement enables those injured by Defendants’ alleged unfair and deceptive business practices to make a complete recovery and requires Defendants take steps to prevent consumers from being misled in the future.

The Court has scheduled a final approval hearing to be held on June 18, 2020, at 10 a.m.; any Class Member who wants to object to the settlement or the request for attorneys’ fees or to exclude themselves from the settlement must do so by April 27, 2020.  Details and further information are available at, where you can also obtain copies of the NOTICE OF PROPOSED CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT and the CLAIM FORM.  For further information about the Notice or the Settlement, you may contact Rust Consulting at (866) 403-6541, or by email at  You may also contact Class Counsel at: Wolf Popper LLP, 845 Third Avenue, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10022, Tel: (212) 759‐4600, Fax: (212) 486‐2093, Email:

Wolf Popper LLP Brings Class Action on Behalf of Patients Who Received Surprise Emergency Room Physician Bills from EmCare Related Physician Groups after Going to an In-Network hospital in California

Wolf Popper filed a class action on behalf of patients who went to an in-network emergency department in California and were charged inflated rates for out-of-network physician services by a company called EmCare, owned by Envision Healthcare. The complaint alleges that EmCare failed to disclose information that would allow patients to avoid—or even know that they were receiving—out-of-network care at an in-network hospital, and then overcharged patients for out-of-network physician services, billing at rates far beyond the fair market value of the services. For further information about this case, please contact any of the following Wolf Popper attorneys:

Emily Madoff

Patricia I. Avery

Related Practice Area